Northeastern University

Page Content   Main Links   Local Links   Utility Links   Footer Links

Bouvé College of Health Sciences at Northeastern University


Adolescents need tailored social services packages to succeed

Print this Page   Home > News > 2012 > Adolescents need tailored social services packages to succeed

October 09, 2012


Ado­les­cents from high-​​poverty neigh­bor­hoods tend to face many mental-​​health chal­lenges, but the solu­tion lies not in finding another place to live, according to pub­lished research by a North­eastern Uni­ver­sity pro­fessor and her colleagues.

Theresa Osypuk, an assis­tant pro­fessor in the Depart­ment of Health Sci­ences in the Bouvé Col­lege of Health Sci­ences, and an inter­dis­ci­pli­nary team of researchers and clin­i­cians recently pub­lished their find­ings in Pedi­atrics and Archives of Gen­eral Psy­chi­atry, two pro­fes­sional peer-​​reviewed journals.

They found that ado­les­cents who have pre-​​existing health con­di­tions or had been exposed to a vio­lent crime while living in public housing did not ben­efit from moving into private-​​market rental prop­er­ties. In some cases, their mental health grew worse.

The researchers ana­lyzed data from a pro­gram spon­sored by the United States Depart­ment of Housing and Urban Devel­op­ment called Moving to Oppor­tu­nity. Under the pro­gram, Osypuk explained, fam­i­lies from the nation's most impov­er­ished neigh­bor­hoods were offered vouchers to move out of public housing and into private-​​market rental prop­er­ties. Ado­les­cent par­tic­i­pants of the pro­gram, as well as a con­trol group that did not receive vouchers, reported on their mental health four to seven years after moving.

While other researchers have pre­vi­ously ana­lyzed the same data, Osypuk's team used more robust ana­lyt­ical methods to tease out new infor­ma­tion that may end up being used to help shape policy reform.

In par­tic­ular, the researchers found that girls with health prob­lems and those in fam­i­lies that expe­ri­enced a vio­lent crime in the six months prior to moving did not expe­ri­ence a change in mental health after relo­cating; girls without a recent his­tory of vio­lence or health con­cerns ben­e­fited from the move. Boys, on the other hand, never ben­e­fited from the move and those with health prob­lems or whose fam­i­lies had recently been exposed to vio­lence expe­ri­enced a decline in mental health.

Osypuk's team and other researchers have attrib­uted the gender dis­crep­ancy to the unique chal­lenges facing boys and girls. "Girls may be escaping sexual harass­ment and threats of sexual vio­lence when they move away from public housing into lower poverty neigh­bor­hoods," said Osypuk.

On the other hand, the social rela­tion­ships that boys form in their neigh­bor­hoods may play a cru­cial role in their mental health, and moving may cause those rela­tion­ships to suffer. Addi­tion­ally, the strate­gies boys use to nav­i­gate the social struc­ture of a high-​​poverty neigh­bor­hood may be unhelpful or even detri­mental in more affluent areas.

The find­ings sug­gest that there is no single solu­tion for helping impov­er­ished youth. "Our results point to the impor­tance of tai­loring social ser­vices for the spe­cific needs of fam­i­lies, and pro­viding social ser­vices across more than one sector," said Osypuk.

She sug­gested that at-​​risk ado­les­cents with a recent his­tory of vio­lence would ben­efit from receiving mental-​​health coun­seling, or infor­ma­tion on spe­cial­ized school pro­grams. As Osypuk put it, "We can't just pro­vide housing vouchers to these kids who are very vul­ner­able on var­ious dif­ferent dimensions."

It may seem obvious that indi­vid­uals with dif­ferent expe­ri­ences will respond to inter­ven­tions in dif­ferent ways, but Osypuk hopes that her study will estab­lish the sig­nif­i­cance of finding an inter­dis­ci­pli­nary solu­tion to reducing the effects of neigh­bor­hood poverty on our nation's youth.

"The public tends to think that health­care is the main pre­dictor of health," she said. But other fac­tors, she added, such as income, edu­ca­tion and housing, are also social deter­mi­nants of health.

Main Links

Local Links

Text Only Options

Top of page

Text Only Options

Open the original version of this page.

Usablenet Assistive is a UsableNet product. Usablenet Assistive Main Page.