University of Florida

FlaLawOnline -

Skip to main Content   Search   Main Navigation   Resources   Website   Social   Address   What is this view

Florida Supreme Court justices discuss importance of independent judiciary

Published: October 22nd, 2012

Category: News

Dean Emeritus Jon Mills, at right, introduces Florida Supreme Court justices during a discussion of the importance of an independent judiciary. (Photo by Marcela Suter)

By Felicia Holloman (3L)

Marbury v. Madison. Brown v. Board of Education. These are some of the most well-known and influential cases in history, but also some of the most unpopular or controversial during the time of the rulings. The rulings may not have been possible without an independent judicial branch — one free of political bias and societal whims.

Florida Supreme Court Justices Barbara J. Pariente, R. Fred Lewis, Peggy A. Quince, and Jorge Labarga spoke candidly at UF Law Oct. 18 about the importance of judicial independence and the challenge to maintain an unbiased court system. The justices arrived to a lively Martin H. Levin Advocacy Center courtroom packed with students, faculty and staff.

Dean Emeritus Jon Mills gave opening remarks and said “We take for granted what the Constitution did when it created an independent judiciary.”

Mills noted that Florida’s judicial system was not always independent of politics. Prior to the 1970s, judges ran for election.

Lewis remembers the time of judicial elections and discussed discouraging experiences as a young lawyer campaigning for Shelby Highsmith for Florida Supreme Court justice.

“(The experience) made me wonder if I had selected the right profession,” Lewis said. “The state was in an awful mess.”

It was not until 1972 that Florida judicial elections became non-partisan. According to Pariente, non-partisan elections reflect the belief that judges should not “fear that their livelihood or tenure” would be in jeopardy due to an unpopular ruling.

Labarga noted the backlash for his ruling as a circuit court judge in Bush v. Gore.

“I followed the rule of law. Some people cannot accept that,” Labarga said, who then joked that he was glad to have been four years away from an election at the time of the ruling.

Judicial independence brings stability to courts. According to Quince, stability means citizens will know what to expect from their court experience.

“Win or lose, you will know you are coming before a judge that is fair and impartial,” Quince said.

The discussion comes ahead of the Nov. 6 election on whether to retain Pariente, Quince, and Lewis. The Florida Republican Party recently announced that it opposes retention of the justices, and conservative groups are campaigning against them.

Voters decide every six years whether to retain Florida Supreme Court justices.

Pariente expressed concern over the increasing politicization of judicial elections. “We now have super PACs, many outside the state, trying to impact elections.”

“There is a conscious, very dedicated attempt to involve partisan politics in the judiciary,” agreed Justice Lewis.

However, Justice Pariente hopes that citizens will not allow the judiciary “to be bought” in the coming election.

The panel was moderated by Carl Schwait, an adjunct professor of law, a member of The Florida Bar Board of Governors, and a senior partner at Dell Graham, P.A. The Gerald T. Bennett Inn of Court and The Florida Bar Law Student Division sponsored the event.




Social links


What is this view?

You are using a dynamic assistive view of the University of Florida site. It has all the same data and features of the original site but formatted just with assistive users in mind. It has links and content reorganized to aid assistive users and has controls at the bottom under assistive options that allow you to control key aspects such as font size and contrast colors etc.
This is not a separate text-only site, it's a dynamic view that uses unique technology from Usablenet to give assistive users better, more accessible access to the same content and features as all users that use the graphic view of the site.

Assistive Options

Top of page

Assistive Options

Open the original version of this page.

Usablenet Assistive is a Usablenet product. Usablenet Assistive Main Page.